Plenty of Settler Colonialism has been done as part of civil wars, because plenty of wars have the killing and replacing of identity as the motif.
Happened in the Punjabi and Tamil regions of india for instance. You can’t just go “yeah but that was during a civil war” and have the ethnic violence or identity replacement aspects of war go away.
Except the Panjab and Tamil region examples aren’t the same, because Panjabi and Tamili are both considered ethnic/cultural minorities who are historically marginalized by the ruling class in India.
That’s fundamentally different from the PRC-ROC conflict which is between two political groups that are both Mandarin-speaking Han Chinese.
So again, that would be closer to the marginalization of Cantonese-speaking ethnic minority groups in the southern regions of China. Or the settler-colonialism taking place in the Uyghur Xinjiang region or annexed Tibet.
Honestly I don’t even know what you’re arguing against because you seem to keep contradicting yourself in order to refute arguments that I never made…
Plenty of Settler Colonialism has been done as part of civil wars, because plenty of wars have the killing and replacing of identity as the motif.
Happened in the Punjabi and Tamil regions of india for instance. You can’t just go “yeah but that was during a civil war” and have the ethnic violence or identity replacement aspects of war go away.
Except the Panjab and Tamil region examples aren’t the same, because Panjabi and Tamili are both considered ethnic/cultural minorities who are historically marginalized by the ruling class in India.
That’s fundamentally different from the PRC-ROC conflict which is between two political groups that are both Mandarin-speaking Han Chinese.
So again, that would be closer to the marginalization of Cantonese-speaking ethnic minority groups in the southern regions of China. Or the settler-colonialism taking place in the Uyghur Xinjiang region or annexed Tibet.
Honestly I don’t even know what you’re arguing against because you seem to keep contradicting yourself in order to refute arguments that I never made…