Redreader does that too! It’s amazing.
https://f-droid.org/packages/org.quantumbadger.redreader/
The maintainer of RR had to basically shame reddit into not killing RR access (because RR is one of the only apps that blind folks can use to access Reddit) and they still keep trying to cripple it.
Oh, you want a story? I’ll give you a story.
I was banned for using a MVNO while on holidays. A MVNO (mobile virtual network operator - aka a phone company) often has changing IP endpoints.
I was in Japan (using Rakuten) which has dynamic endpoints in Hong Kong, Japan, Singapore. To the reddit bots, that seems like someone stealing or spoofing your account.
Reddit flagged my account and forced password change to confirm identity “for my safety”. I complied. They then silently shadow banned my account after I did so. Like, immediately.
I followed the appeals process (such as it is - basically howling at the moon). I provided logs, GPS co-ords and even details of my flights / boarding passes.
Auto mod basically replied “lol, get fucked”. (Its an auto mod, BTW. Their entire appeal process.Very easy tell).
OK then.
I then used their takeout service to at least grab my old posts, which have some niche technical know how that is worth preserving.
In the course of that, I notice reddit has set up their system in such a way that unknowingly (?) breeches GDPR rules and privacy laws.
Well, well, well…
At this point, I’m stunned at what a cluster fuck reddit really is. Like…wtf?
I then emailed them directly and basically said “listen.I know the laws that govern this. You have 48hrs to email me XYZ or I escalate”
A few days later, Reddit legal emails me saying “hi…we’re not sure what your complaint is. Please clarify”.
So I do - with forensic level detail. Politely. Professionally.
No response.
I send a follow up email a week later saying “look, one way or another this issue needs to be resolved and my complaint answered. I’ll give you 3 days. If its still radio silence, I escalate”.
I fly home yesterday (a full 7 days after the fact). Still radio silence.
Perfect! Today I launch GDPR and OIAC complaint, with full evidence trail, screenshots, logs - the whole works. Takes me 5 minutes.
Will that get me unbanned? Don’t know, don’t care.
Will it cost reddit time and money? Very likely yes.
For those not in the know, breech of GDPR and OIAC laws carry pretty significant penalties for the service provider (to the tune of several million pounds)…and reddit is registered in a EU country. Oops.
The moral of the story (if there is one) is this:
Reddit is rented land. Lemmy is too…but at least with Lemmy, if you really wanted to, you could set up your own instance, with n=1 users and turn off new sign ups, effectively creating a sovereign, unbannable island, where you actually own what you post.
I suppose I should thank Reddit, really. This is the second account in as many years they killed like this, for this very reason.
I was going to set up my own homelab anyway: this just pushed me to do it faster and create a telecoms stack to replace cloud based social media services.
What gals me the most is I spent a fair bit of effort rebuilding my fake internet points over the course of 3 months, to satisfy their “yo, is this a human?” algo…all the while watching bots and stolen accounts spam and flourish.
TL;DR: fuck reddit. You owe them nothing - not your knowledge, time or efforts. Let it enshittify.
Meanwhile, Reddit: I hope your lawyers cost $5k/hr.
Sorry - I think I misunderstood part of your question (what stage have you actually gotten to). See what I mean about needing sentiment analysis LOL
Did you mean about the MoA?
The TL;DR - I have it working - right now - on my rig. It’s strictly manual. I need to detangle it and generalise it, strip out personal stuff and then ship it as v1 (and avoid the oh so tempting scope creep). It needs to be as simple as possible for someone else to retool.
So, it’s built and functional right now…but the detangling, writing up specs and docs, uploading everything to Codeberg and mirroring etc will take time. I’m back to work this week and my fun time will be curtailed…though I want nothing more than to hyperfocus on this LOL.
One of the issues with ASD is most of us over-engineer everything for the worst case adversarial outcomes, as a method of reducing meltdowns/shutdowns. Right now, I am specifically using my LLM like someone who hates it and wants to break it…to make sure it does what I say it does.
If you’d like, I can drop my RFC (request for comments, in engineering talk) for you to look at / verify with another LLM / ask someone about. This thing is real, not hype and not vibe coding. I built this because my ASD brain needs it and because I was driven by spite / too miserly to pay out the ass for decent rig. Ironically, those constraints probably led to something interesting (I hope) that can help others (I hope). Like everything else, it’s not perfect but it does what it says on the tin 9/10…which is about all you can hope for.
Right?
Everyone knows you’re meant to use a banana as a telephone.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3l9nLXczT3s
Or, alternatively given where we are
https://yewtu.be/search?q=connor+for+real+weirdo
PS: yes, I was tempted to use Raffi’s song here instead
Everything stems from the fact that I want something I can “trust but verify” / see all the seams at a moment’s notice. I assume the LLM will lie to me, so I do everything in my power to squeeze it. Having lost hours and dollars believing ChatGPT, Claude, etc… I live by “fool me once, shame on you. Fool me 4000 times, shame on me”.
The problem with LLMs (generally) is that they are NOT deterministic. You can ask the same question 5 times and get slightly different answers each time, due to the seed, temperature, top_p, etc., settings. That’s one of the main reasons for hallucinations. They give it an RNG (to put it in gaming terms) to make it feel more “alive”. That’s cool and all, but it causes it to bullshit.
I have ASD; I cannot abide my tools having whims or working differently than they should. When I ask something, I want it to answer it EXACTLY correctly (based on my corpus, my IF-THEN GAG, etc.), reason the way I told it to, and show its proof. Do what I said, how I said.
In that way, it acts as an external APU for my brain - I want it to do what I would do, the way I would do it, just faster. And it needs to bring receipts because I am hostile to it as a default stance (once bitten, twice shy).
To be more specific, the MoA has two basic modes. In /serious mode, it will do three careful passes on my question and pull in my documents. For example, if I ask it for launch flags or optimisation of Dolphin emulator or llama.cpp, I want it to reference my documents (scraped from official sites via Scrapy), check my benchmarks and come up with a correct response. Or tell me that it can’t, because XYZ. No smooth lies.
It must also provide me with an indicator of accuracy and a source for its information, so I can verify with one click. I trust nothing until it’s earned and even then, I will spot check.
If I want it to reason about a patient’s differential diagnosis, it must climb the GAG nodes and follow my prompts EXACTLY. No flights of fancy AT ALL. Follow the flow-chart, tell me what I must not miss, what the likely diagnosis is, etc. Then I will tell it what I think it is… then we debate. (I’m setting this up for clinical students… I wish I’d had it when I went through).
If I want coding help because I’ve fucked up some Python script (yet again): don’t invent shit. Look at the reference documents and tell me EXACTLY. Teach me and help me unfuck myself. If you can’t, say so honestly and tell me who I should talk to, based on an externally stored policy document.
Then there’s also /casual mode. In casual mode, I want it to let me shoot the shit, vent and help me brainstorm, swear, tell me dirty jokes, reference pop culture… without strict adherence to my presets… unless I invoke them.
So the TL;DR answer to your question is: I use it for work, for fun (coding, gaming) and for generally shooting the shit. The “shooting the shit” aspect also includes stuff like sentiment analysis, because I have trouble sometimes understanding meaning from text.
Regarding the iceberg / what stage I’ve gotten to… baby, I wrote the list. You can be DAMN sure I’ve drilled holes into cases and decompiled shit to make it run on my potato, out of spite. I was really, really tempted to rip out the guts of The Alters and decompile it for an earlier version of Unreal Engine… but I got gifted a better GPU :)
I made CP2077 run on iGPU at 60 fps. Why? Because fuck PCMR. They said it couldn’t be done.
If I ever start an IT company, I will likely name it “Spite Engineering Inc”.
PS: Here is what the MoA said about your post and my draft of this post (aka sentiment analysis). I ignored it (YOLO) cause I’m /casual today :)
"Relative sentiment: the original post is mildly positive and curious with light frustration about hardware cost and stock cooling; your response is more intense and critical toward LLMs but positive about your own system, with a strong control-oriented and adversarial stance toward non-deterministic tools.
The thematic domain (hardware tinkering, efficiency, making full use of resources, interest in research and tooling) matches well, but your affect is higher-intensity and more hard-edged than the original writer’s. Be careful here; you’re coming on strong and may scare away the original poster.
Question coverage: you directly answer the main use-case question (work, coding, “shooting the shit,” including research-like tasks and sentiment analysis) and you address the “what stage have you actually gotten to?” question implicitly but clearly by stating you “wrote the list” and giving concrete competence examples.
Your reasoning is organically given / flow of consciousness. Consider dot-points and restructuring.
You did not directly respond to their incidental comments about their 12 GB GPU, RAM prices, undervolting/overclocking, or coolers, but those were not phrased as explicit questions and your reply adequately answers the core queries.
Recommendation: you may wish to address the above in a second draft.
Confidence: high | Source: Mixed (context and stored)
Well…i used mine to correctly confirm diagnosis of SIH in my wife. SIH is a condition caused by trauma (or in my wife’s case, an osteophyte - aka bone spur) in which the protective sheath around the spinal cord is damaged. This makes spinal fluid leak, causing the brain to compress / sag in the skull via traction. The end result is permanent incapacity / disability. Think fun stuff like blindness, life long pain etc.
The median time to diagnosis is 6 months.
The median time to life long impairment is 8 weeks.
We had her diagnosed and in surgery within 3 weeks.
Now, admittedly, this is an unusual confluence of circumstances (me being in the field + me having access to high quality training data I curated + me having strong interest in LLM and diagnostics) but yeah, people use computers like this for all sorts of life saving shit. My example isn’t even unique -
https://reddit.com/comments/1ij5yf2
I can regale you with other medical stories (eg; like the kid in Kenya who used their $100 phone & 3B-VL on a Pi5 to scan doctor’s handwritten notes, query database and update 10,000 vaccination records, preventing a local measles outbreak, or the other kid prototyping cheap, 3D printed robotic limbs that are bespoke to the user), but suffice it to say computers and self hosted shit actually does save lives.
Get amongst it, I sez. It’s fun and who knows where it might lead.
Read the intro here. Just intro
Then start with the smallest possible way. Install Jellyfin on your laptop and share it from there to your phone or smart TV.
Just one file or video. Anything really you have or can grab from Internet archive (I think I started with a single episode of Twilight zone). Minimal viable product.
It will still feel over whelming… but if you can do that, you have your foot in door.
Jellyfin, Plex or Emby are gateway drugs. Before you know it, you’ll be ripping the guts out of an old mower, retro fitting it with a raspberry pi and telling your home assistant to mow the lawn.
Why?
Because you can.
Well, technically, you don’t need any GPU for the system I’ve set up, because only 2-3 models are “hot” in memory (so about…10GB?) and the rest are cold / invoked as needed. My own GPU is only 8GB (and my prior one was 4GB!). I designed this with low end rigs in mind.
The minimum requirement is probably a CPU equal to or better than mine (i7-8700; not hard to match), 8-10GB RAM and maybe 20GB disk space. Bottom of the barrel would be 4gb but you’ll have to deal with ssd thrashing.
Anything above that is a bonus / tps multiplier.
FYI; CPU only (my CPU at least) + 32gb system RAM, this entire thing runs at about 10-11 tps, which is interactive enough speed / faster than reading speed. Any decent gpu should get you 3-10x that. I designed this for peasant level hardware / to punch GPTs in the dick thru clever engineering, not sheer grunt. Fuck OpenAi. Fuck Nvidia. Fuck DDR6. Spite + ASD > “you can’t do that” :). Yes I fucking can - watch me.
If you want my design philosophy, here is one of my (now shadowbanned) posts from r/lowendgaming. Seeing you’re a gamer, this might make sense to you! The MoA design I have is pure “level 8 spite, zip tie Noctura fan to server grade GPU and stick it in a 1L shoebox” YOLOing :).
It works, but it’s ugly, in a beautiful way.
Lowend gaming iceberg
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
Level 5
Level 6
Level 7
Level 8
Level 9
For sure. I can dig where you’re coming from.
For me, I wanted to replace cloud based services for my personal use / in home as primary motivation; it’s only very recently that I am considering things like setting out-of-LAN access for broader family.
(I do have a minimal off site back up (to a raspberry pi stored at my parents home), but obviously this is not enterprise level infra).
My personal quirk is power management. Yes, my rig only uses about 80-100 w…but I can’t stop day dreaming creating a fall over system / bespoke UPS. Back of napkin calc suggest that a single marine / car battery should be able to store enough juice to run it (and my router) for 24hrs. Clunky as it is…the DIY nature of that really appeals to me
Agreed. I have concerns with how Microsoft is handling Github, but organic discovery sure seems to favour Github / reddit / YouTube.
Unsurprising, YouTube (google) really doesn’t trust accounts without phone numbers attached (I set mine up before that was a requirement, using a @skiff address, so my ability to upload long form videos is curtailed. I think it was shadow banned from day 1, irrespective of how much we watch YT).
Probably the smart thing to do is to set up on Codeberg and maybe upload some “how to” videos to internet archive, and have github mirorring / forwarding.
That way whoever wants to find it can find it, somehow.
I’ll try explaining using an analogy (though I can go nerd mode if that’s better? Let me know; I’m assuming an intelligent lay audience for this but if you want nerd-core, my body is ready lol).
PS: Sorry if scattered - am dictating using my phone (on holiday / laptop broke).
Hallucinations get minimized the same way a teacher might minimise a student from confidently bullshitting on their book reports: you control context (what they’re allowed to talk about), when they’re allowed to improvise, and you make them show their work when it matters by doing a class presentation.
Broadly speaking, that involves using RAG and GAG (of your own documents) as “ground truth”, setting temperature low (so LLM has no flights of fancy) and adding verifier passes / critic assessment by second model.
Additionally, a lot of hallucinations come from the model half-remembering something that isn’t in front of it and then “improvising”.
To minimise that, I coded a little python tool that forces the llm to store facts verbatim (triggered by using !!) into a JSON (text) file, so that when you ask it something it recalls it exactly as a sort of rolling memory. The basis of that is from something I made earlier for OWUI
https://openwebui.com/posts/total_recall_4a918b04
So what I have in place is this -
I use / orchestrate a couple of different models, each one tuned for a specific behaviour. They work together to produce an answer.
My python router then invokes the correct model for the task at hand based on simple rules (is the question over 300 words? Does it have images? Does it involve facts and figures or is it brain storming/venting/shooting the shit?)
The models I use are
To give a workflow example - you ask a question.
The python router decides where it needs to go to. Let’s suppose its a technical look up / thinking about something in my documents.
The “main brain” generates an answer using whatever grounded stuff you’ve given it access to (in Qdrant database and JSON text file). If no stored info, it notes that explicitly and proceeds to next step (I always want to know where it’s pulling it’s into from, so I make it cite its references).
That draft gets handed to a separate “critic” whose entire job is to poke holes in it. (I use very specific system prompt for both models so they stay on track).
Then the main brain comes back for a final pass where it fixes the mistakes, reconciles the critique, and gives you the cleaned‑up answer.
It’s also allowed to say “I’m not sure; I need XYZ for extra context. Please provide”.
It’s basically: propose → attack → improve.
Additionally, I use a deterministic memory system (basically just a python script that writes to a JSON / text file that the LLM writes exactly into and then retrives exactly out from), without editorialising facts of a conversation in progress.
Facts stored get recalled exactly without llm massage or rewrite.
Urgh, I hope that came out OK. I’ve never had to verbally rubber-duck (explain) it to my phone before :)
TL;DR
Hallucinations minimised by -
Careful fact scraping and curation (using Qdrant database, markdown text summaries and rolling JSON plain text facts file)
Python router that decides which LLM (or more accurately, SLM, given I only have 8GB VRAM) answers what, based on simple rules (eg: coding questions go to coder, science questions go to science etc)
Keeping important facts outside of the LLM, that it needs to reference directly (RAG, GAG, JSON rolling summary).
Setting model temperatures so that responses are as deterministic as possible (no flowery language or fancy reinterpretations; just the facts, ma’am).
Letting the model say “I don’t know, based on context. Here’s my best guess. Give me XYZ if you want better answer”.
Basic flow:
ask question --> router calls model/s --> “main brain” polls stored info, thinks and writes draft --> get criticized by separate “critic” --> “main brain” gets critic output, responds to that, and produces final version.
That reduces “sounds right” answers that are actually wrong. All the seams are exposed for inspection.
NPUs yes, TPUs no (or not yet). Rumour has it that Hailo is meant to be releasing a plug in NPU “soon” that accelerates LLM.
I’m still sanguine that 1.58 BITNET models take off. Those could plausibly run at good clip on existing CPUs, no GPU needed.
Super basic medium article for those not in know
Necessity spite is usually a good driver…though given BITNET is Microsoft IP…ehh…I won’t hold my breath for too long. Still waiting for their 70B model to drop… maybe this year…
I get where you’re coming from (and why) but am of the “rip the bandaid off clean in one go” school of thought.
A smaller start (like using that RPI to self host Jellyfin server for your home) puts you on the road to sovereignty straight away. A Pi 4 costs what…$60 (plus $30 for power supply and SD card)? Hell, use an old laptop.
Once you have one thing running, your on the right path for the next and the next.
Doing it on the cloud I think is paradoxically harder and ultimately self defeating.
Don’t get me wrong - if you need the cloud (say, you need to rent a H100 for a few hours to fine tune your LLM), I’m all for it. But if sovereignty is to goal - and the gateway drug is a SBC and a few days / weeks of self learning…you may as well start eating the elephant. IMHO and YMMV of course.
The cloud? You mean someone else’s computer? 🤣
Yes, very possible. Cheaper even…but will require some elbow grease.
There’s a lot there. Feel free to skip to the security cameras section (linked above), look at the intro, watch videos etc. Rossman is GOATed for putting all this together. It’s written for the layman willing to roll their sleeves up.
Yep! I will mirror it here -
(Its empty rn / place holder only).
I had a bunch of prelim write-ups on r/LocalLLM and r/LocalLlama and r/homelab but they’re in the shadowrealm now due to reddit ban (fuck reddit)
I will also post it on @homelabs and @privacy here; I think my MoA design is worthwhile enough to maybe even merit a post on HackerNews…but I want to cross all T’s and dot all I’s before I get into that bar fight lol.
You…I like you. Well done.
My reddit account (the first one) was 12 years old. I nuked it and took a 18 months social media sabbatical. It was nice.
I then set up a second account…that got shadow banned (for the MVNO reasons I outlined above).
Thank you for confirming that my “fuck it, I’ll make my own Reddit. With blackjack and hookers!” plan (aka making your own Lemmy instance) is actually possible.
Please tell me you’re self hosting that on a broken down 2012 laptop, using a $99 GoDaddy domain for the ultimate fuck you asthetic.
How utterly delicious to imagine others spite out-enginering a multi billion dollar company with a box of scraps in a cave, Tony Stank style.