In America, YES WE ABSOLUTELY DO. Solitary confinement is considered torture and yet is regularly used not only on our prison populations (for even those serving time for minor non-violent offenses) but also on our children in juvenile detention. Nevermind that prisoners are subjected sexual violence, medical neglect, live in dangerous/unsafe conditions, are used as forced labor (and punished if they refuse) - seriously I could go on. We should be focused on rehabilitation but instead have gone all in on punative and psychological torment and no one notices or cares because “they’re criminals.”
The issue is that contempt is not a rubber stamp here. Members of the military still have the right to free speech, a requirement to refuse unlawful orders, and other rights and duties surrounding speech and speaking up. The real violation was that he did it in uniform. DoD 1344.10.
With everything we know about Trump, who openly wants to be a dictator, and his thin skinned administration, this reeks of trying to push the line and make an example. Confinement to quarters and a restriction on talking to the media would be far more appropriate for the pre trial period.
Watson has been convicted of no crime. Military law says a service member awaiting trial cannot be punished, and confinement may not be any more rigorous than the circumstances require.
He has been charged, he is being held pretrial. Pretty normal criminal trial, not sure how the military handles bail. It’s the conditions, solitary for a poor reason, that I see is the issue. He definitely broke military law, but he is being punished harshly to make a point to the rest of us.
confinement may not be any more rigorous than the circumstances require.
So did they determine what the circumstances require? Because I think that’s something courts decide. And this takes the headline from “they are punishing innocent guy for criticizing Trump” to “we think they may be holding him in solitary confinement without proper justification but we don’t know for sure”.
This guy did nothing wrong. Neither did the other service members who are currently being tortured in solitary confinement by their own for speaking out.
Spend a day in solitary confinement and then see if you still feel that way. Matter of fact, you could just sit on your couch doing literally nothing for 5 hours and see how that goes. It’s still not as bad, and I bet you’d hate it.
Yup, that’s a crime for US military officers. UCMJ 88
Do we usually torture people over committing a crime?
In America, YES WE ABSOLUTELY DO. Solitary confinement is considered torture and yet is regularly used not only on our prison populations (for even those serving time for minor non-violent offenses) but also on our children in juvenile detention. Nevermind that prisoners are subjected sexual violence, medical neglect, live in dangerous/unsafe conditions, are used as forced labor (and punished if they refuse) - seriously I could go on. We should be focused on rehabilitation but instead have gone all in on punative and psychological torment and no one notices or cares because “they’re criminals.”
Yes
The issue is that contempt is not a rubber stamp here. Members of the military still have the right to free speech, a requirement to refuse unlawful orders, and other rights and duties surrounding speech and speaking up. The real violation was that he did it in uniform. DoD 1344.10.
With everything we know about Trump, who openly wants to be a dictator, and his thin skinned administration, this reeks of trying to push the line and make an example. Confinement to quarters and a restriction on talking to the media would be far more appropriate for the pre trial period.
Have you read the article?
He has been charged, he is being held pretrial. Pretty normal criminal trial, not sure how the military handles bail. It’s the conditions, solitary for a poor reason, that I see is the issue. He definitely broke military law, but he is being punished harshly to make a point to the rest of us.
bump
So did they determine what the circumstances require? Because I think that’s something courts decide. And this takes the headline from “they are punishing innocent guy for criticizing Trump” to “we think they may be holding him in solitary confinement without proper justification but we don’t know for sure”.
As they say, military justice is to justice what military music is to music…
Oh no you didn’t
It’s one thing to charge him for violating that code, but keeping him in solitary confinement until Feb is torture and cruel.
Doesn’t make it moral or right.
Legal does not equal moral, ethical, or correct.
Legal means some jackass somewhere decided it was ok.
That’s it.
Technically it just means some jackass somewhere didn’t decide it wasn’t ok.
So is murdering children.
This guy did nothing wrong. Neither did the other service members who are currently being tortured in solitary confinement by their own for speaking out.
Piss on the troops.
Edgy!
Spend a day in solitary confinement and then see if you still feel that way. Matter of fact, you could just sit on your couch doing literally nothing for 5 hours and see how that goes. It’s still not as bad, and I bet you’d hate it.
Land of the free. The home of free speech. The bastion of democracy…
Those fighting for freedom sacrifice many of the freedoms we enjoy.
But we’re talking about the United States military.